
How much are we in charge of ourselves, and to what extent is the world controlling us?
I do not mean in a political sense.
Rather, to what degree have automatic, shortcut, and routine tendencies taken us over and come to control a good deal of what we think, do, say, and accept without provoking our consideration?
On one level, we have become watchers. Our kind seeks and embraces help from others, risking dependency. In the name of efficiency and speed, we permit machines to think for us.
The Harvard Gazette asked faculty members about this concern in an essay that leads with the following:
A recent MIT Media Lab study reported that “excessive reliance on AI-driven solutions” may contribute” to “cognitive atrophy” and shrinking of critical thinking abilities.
People listen to podcasts and AI guidance and, in some cases, set aside interest in real people for interaction and companionship.
Many work from home without the sense of touch and the physical closeness of smiles, wrinkles, scent, and conversation with others.
We sit in front of computer screens, rather than moving or experiencing the natural world.

Do we, young people in particular, have the skill to relate to and form attachments with others? AI conversations are less troublesome, after all. The design of chatbots ensures they are agreeable.
Actual people are more complicated, as Sherry Turkle discusses in her recent book, Artificial Intimacy.
Countless folks communicate via email and text, and therefore less often through thoughtful telephone conversations or the longhand writing of letters, if indeed we can do the latter. Reading goes on, but some avoid complete books in favor of summaries and condensed descriptions.
AI can write for us, too.
In times past, students memorized poems and recited them to classmates. The practice was long since abandoned in many places.
Driving a car depended on learning and recalling the route from one place to another without the benefit of a phone or the auto’s built-in assistance. A map was used for temporary guidance until we memorized the directions.
The skill-building that children and adults acquired thereby helped create intellectual capacity and independence. Moreover, before the advent of written language, mankind depended on memory in ways we can only imagine.
The Western world has advanced in time-saving devices in recent years, but also lost a great deal.
What’s wrong with this, you may ask? Women and men adapt to those transformations. You and I cram more work into the passing moments, as expected by those we work for and our needs.
I wonder, though.
Do we stop to think about how alterations at bullet speed have modified the once-normal world? Do we puzzle out the meaning of events, AI, working at home, and other changes? Considering this, can we rely on our own opinions rather than others’?
To what extent do we reflect on the condition of the planet we live on and on how others manage, struggle, and attempt to survive elsewhere? Do we imagine what their lives would be like if we shared those circumstances?

Do we think through the direction toward which strangers and we are headed, and ponder humanity’s moral state?
Hannah Arendt, the philosopher and scholar of fascism, believed that thinking is a moral activity. It requires the capacity to evaluate, including judgment of ourselves. She believed in the value of a dialogue, an internal one-on-one conversation.
All this is a responsibility and a necessity to reach beyond what we are told and the manipulation of our thoughts. Without thinking clearly, without challenging our beliefs, we risk shallowness and vulnerability to persuasion that can lead us to harm others, as Arendt understood it.
Those manipulations increase. Distraction, work, and raising a family leave us without the time, attention, and desire to create and contribute, and to recognize how we can impact where we are and who we are—who we will become.
The future is unknown and unknowable. It has never been a matter of certainty. We are left to our ingenuity to fashion what we can within the external conditions in which we live, while recognizing that hope will not take us all the way to our desired destination.
To move ahead, then, we must work with others, think outside the box, reflect on our lives, personality and character, and learn to think critically and independently.
Liberation from the constraints of our common existence, its endless nonhuman (AI) influences, and human influencers must be considered and pursued.
We move too fast. Is it too much to say we are cooperative hostages, like the prisoners in Plato’s cave, so well blinded to ourselves, unable to focus on what is the truth of the human condition that we don’t give it a second thought?
You decide.
It has to be you.
========
The top image is titled Morning at the Golden Gate Bridge, San Francisco by Grombo.
The second one is A Man with a Shopping Bag Walks Along a Platform at Dundas Subway Station in Toronto as a Train Rushes Past by Radomianin.
Finally, A Snake Charmer, India, from the Frank and Frances Carpenter Collection (Library of Congress). All three pictures were sourced from Wikimedia Commons.
