Being Remembered

What might it be like to be a ghost? In addition to witnessing the future, you would discover what the living talk and write about. Not their legacy, but yours, once you are gone.

Will you be remembered? Did you leave a mark on the world? Did the impact of your existence last only as long as it took you to write your name on the ocean’s sandy shore, gone once the tide came in and erased it?

When we were both 16, a friend of mine hoped for more. “I want to do something great in my life,” he said. His time on earth did afford significant acclaim as a college professor who won awards for his teaching. Students thought the world of him, and he wrote a couple of books and many journal articles, though they were not widely read. In his eyes, none of this reached greatness. 

The importance he placed on lasting fame became a kind of self-torture, though he didn’t intend it to. 

While he focused on reaching the top of the ladder, his family, friends, loving wife, travel, and comfortable home were insufficient to free him from his fixation on an imaginary, unnamed achievement. 

What about you and me? Well, your children will remember you if you have them; your grandchildren too, if you are given enough life and the opportunity to connect. There will be videos and photos, but no guarantee that they will be perused. 

Many incidental traces of your existence might be put in a box or on a thumb drive. 

A lock of hair and the sound of your recorded voice will last, while the scent of your skin and the fragrance you applied to your body will fade, along with your embrace, and all the kisses, laughter, and smiles that enriched your being.

If you showed kindness and helped others, worked to repair the world, were a transformative leader, or pursued a helping profession, you will be remembered by some of those lucky enough to benefit from your talent and effort. Of course, expert teachers cause ripple effects that extend far beyond the students’ presence in their classes.

Past two generations? Unless you achieved lasting fame, time will likely render your name one of those little recalled. Nonetheless, you needn’t succeed to fashion a name that survives beyond you. Sinners as well as saints also make their mark. 

The drama of your story, the laughter, the pain, the tears, the joy, the gain, and the loss will vanish unless you write your autobiography. No formal scorecard of your life will exist unless you were a professional athlete or Olympic champion.

Ah, but there are exceptions. My friend, Tom Saler, wrote a book about the symphony and opera conductor Carlo Maria Giulini. It is still in press—the only English-language biography of the remarkable man whose life he described. But do note that it is Giulini’s life that is examined, while the writer’s life is not well known.

I expect Tom’s name to survive. That, by itself, is remarkable.

Many of us have created resumes or CVs (Curriculum Vitae). These offer an academic and professional history of a life, but are impersonal. They list one’s surface accomplishments such as university degrees, jobs held, honors, essays, and published research. Job applicants are expected to provide this to their prospective employer, typically a page or two.

Regarding books and the capture of how one moved and spoke, video interviews and memory compilations like Storyworth have become popular, often as gifts from adult children. The loved one chooses questions for the parent to answer, one per week in written or recorded form. After a year, a book is created. 

I have written one of these myself, 400 pages worth.

Why? 

For my children and grandchildren, no one else. 

This is not to keep anything from others. Beyond some of my blog followers and friends, however, I doubt anyone else will care about my thoughts on the time I lived in, the life I led, the things I accomplished, and where I found meaning as the days of my life dissolved. 

Much of what is in the book will not surprise my blog followers. The difference is that some of what I have written for my children and grandchildren is more personal.

None of this means I have dismissed the accomplishments of my working life. I am happy I achieved what I did and believe I have been a lucky man so far. Why “so far?” The ancient Greek sage Solon reminded Croesus, the wealthiest man in the world, that one should never call oneself fortunate until the very end.

I never anticipated the doors that opened for me, but I had the wisdom to walk through them and try to remold myself as I came to understand my weaknesses: what I didn’t like about myself. 

That is part of my story too, but the actual achievements are not much thought about by me. They are in the past, a place I do not now inhabit. 

In the present, I am more focused on the modest amount of time ahead and on what I can do to make the world a little better. Of course, I expect to maintain the relationships I’ve had for many years for as long as possible.

As you might have concluded by now, I am comfortable with the notion of fading away once I pass away. 

Never did I hope to become Napoleon or the aforementioned Giulini. What I have done is more than enough. 

From my perspective, I lived through the best moment in world history in the right country, a land of opportunity and safety, though, regrettably, not for people of color. 

My parents’ modest income was not an impediment to attending fine universities and a splendid graduate school. 

I made marvelous friends and held on to many of them for most of my lifetime. Love pursued me from an unexpected place, and within the family, my wife, children, and I fostered abiding affection. 

My life was crowned with the people I touched and who touched me. I evaluated close to 3,000 individuals and joined others in the shared effort to improve their lives. Some of these folks taught me more than a little about bravery and resilience. I was privileged to receive their emotional openness and trust. 

Over more than twenty years, I had the opportunity to record interviews with many of the men and women of the Chicago Symphony. Their voices and mine live in the Chicago Symphony archives. 

In the recent past, I have decided to say some things to friends—things I have not told them before. It is the why and how of my appreciation of them as we sit together at breakfast or lunch. 

None of us can predict when our end will come. Best to communicate to those we care about why they are precious. 

Were you to ask me what has been the most essential element in my life, I would say it without hesitation: time. The time to do the things I have done, to make mistakes and try again, and to encounter the people who made a difference to me. 

Beyond that necessity there is something more. Should you wish to hear what is most important in the life I have led and am leading, the answer is simple: love.

==========

The first image is “Coming into Miami Last November from Argentina “ by Laura Hedien, with her kind permission. The last is Mucha’s 1905 Madonna of the Lilies.

The End of the Story: What Happens After Therapy?

My Story

Imagine that you are reading a book, the only one of its kind. No other copy of the book exists. That, by itself, makes the volume precious. You find the story compelling. You identify with its lead character. And only then, fully engrossed by the plot, you discover that the last chapter or two are missing.

You are frustrated, aren’t you? Well, now you know a little bit about how a therapist can feel some time after treatment of a patient comes to its end. As the clock ticks away, you find yourself wondering from time to time: how did her life turn out? How is he doing?

Of course, you can call to find out, assuming that you have the correct phone number. Or, you can see if the Internet will avail you any information with which to track your former patient’s post-therapy path. But, usually you don’t. You have other things to do, other patients, other priorities. And, you don’t necessarily wish to invite a kind of contact that will overstep the boundaries of a therapist/client relationship or violate the ethical guidelines of your profession. Still, every so often, you wonder: how did this person’s life turn out after all?

Sometimes, even without taking any initiative, you do learn some things. Your former patient refers a friend to see you and you might inquire as to how your ex-patient is doing. Or, the ex-client writes you a note, almost always of thanks. On the other hand, some of them will recontact you when their lives have again hit a rough spot. In effect, they hope that you can give them a “tune up,” almost in the way that you might do regular maintenance on a car.

A small number of therapists, those who are interested in evaluating their own performance as precisely as possible, do send out questionnaires to ex-patients after six months or a year. That provides some feedback. But mostly what you’d really like to know is how they are doing after five or 10 years. What their life has been like. You’d like to think that time has been kind to them. You hope that their lives have turned out reasonably well. These people, who you have come to know and care about, are mostly decent and good folks, struggling (as we all do) to make the best of things, to have some happiness, to make their lives as interesting and successful and useful as they can. You wish them only the best.

It is not a major tragedy that a therapist does not know “the end of the story” or at least the most recent chapter. It is simply in the nature of the work we do. And, without question, patients also ask the same question: “How is the doc doing? Does he think about me ever? It would be nice to hear his voice.”

Clearly, the answer is yes, we do think back. We don’t remember each and every one of you, but we recall some of you very well. You have enriched us, and I don’t mean by writing a check for our service to you. We learned from you about our craft and about ourselves. We valued and still value your life. As I said, we wish you only the best.

Sometimes relationships continue within a person long after the two people involved have had contact. Rather one-sided, certainly. But, even though you might never know it, I can assure you that some people almost certainly still remember you in a positive way; both therapists and old friends whom you haven’t seen in years. Someone out there may indeed be thinking of you in the very moment you are thinking of her or him.

Isn’t that what everyone wants?

—

The magazine cover illustration above was sourced from Turn685 via Wikimedia Commons.